Monday, May 20, 2013
At Home Plate
Big Mac Provides Big Story
Written by Daniel Paulling (Contact & Archive) on March 08, 2010
  

Albert Pujols may be the most discussed first baseman in Cardinals' camp this spring, but Mark McGwire will be a close second. The former first baseman admitted on January 11 to using steroids throughout his career.

The admission was a move to get ensuing backlash cleared before the Cardinals went to spring training, but it's going to be something written about every new series. McGwire, the golden boy of the Bash Brothers in Oakland and the big slugger of the '98 home run chase, will be a huge topic of discussion.

 

larussa_tony
Tony LaRussa may face his toughest challenge yet in St. Louis this season.
That doesn't include something rather important: suppose a few of the Cardinals hitters slump or the Cardinals finish with a down season offensively. What are people going to say about McGwire then? What is the second guessing going to look like?

Remember: McGwire never coached a day in his life, and he has been out of baseball for nine seasons. The many minor league coaches who have been hoping for a Major League job will tell you it's difficult enough to get one. Plenty of knowledgeable coaches and managers never make it to the Major Leagues. And now McGwire has to prove himself with no background, no training on how to teach hitters.

One thing that should benefit McGwire is that he's hands-on with hitters. He's willing to get into the cages and show hitters what they need to do. But let's not forget Ted Williams couldn't manage the Washington Senators, and he was the second-best hitter of all-time. What makes McGwire's situation any different?

McGwire also worked with Matt Holliday during the 2008-09 offseason. Holliday started the year slowly with the Athletics before dumping what he had learned from McGwire, and he immediately began to hit. Sure, McGwire knows not to make those same changes with Holliday, but isn't Holliday going to have some doubts in his mind when it comes to McGwire?

What if McGwire suggests Holliday shift his weight a little bit more before a pitch and Holliday does that and continues to slump? Baseball is a tricky game, especially with a player's mind, even a superstar like Holliday's. I'm not saying sell on Holliday -- he's still an excellent hitter -- but there's a chance this marriage won't work again. And that's a pretty big deal considering Holliday is the only guy the Cardinals have that will keep opposing pitchers honest in pitching to Pujols.

How well is McGwire going to perform in his first season as a Major League hitting coach? It's difficult to tell. But this has the opportunity of going south for the Cardinals, even with McGwire's knowledge of hitting.

Who knows? He may not be the hitting coach come September if Tony LaRussa follows through with his plan to pinch-hit McGwire if the Cardinals are in a close race.



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
 

At Home Plate Podcast

To listen to or download the latest At Home Plate Podcast, please click here.
To subscribe, click the icon below
Podcast Feed

Donations

If you like At Home Plate, you could show your appreciation by donating a small amount to our team. Thank you very much!

Amount: