Secondary Average

by Ray Flowers
May 16,2005

In my continuing look into explaining sabermetrics to the traditional baseball fan I thought I would cover a fairly simple metric that helps to measures a hitter’s overall effectiveness. What sets apart this metric from others is that it is easy enough to figure out that you don’t need a degree in astrophysics to interpret its meaning nor is it necessary to figure out the mathematics. Basically all you need is to have passed your middle school pre-algebra class and you’ve got this thing licked.

SECONDARY AVERAGE DEFINED

Secondary Average, or SEC, is a sabermetric tool used to gauge a player’s ability to produce extra bases independent of batting average (The total of a player's extra bases on hits, walks, and stolen bases expressed as a percentage of at bats). The statistic basically covers the three primary factors of an offensive contribution outside of AVG-…power (bases), eye (BB) and speed (SB).

What sets SEC apart from other simple metrics is that it takes into account all aspects of a player’s offensive contribution including two lesser-recorded measures, BB and SB. The reason that SEC records SB as well as CS is that too often with the SB all that people see is the positive effects of a successful stolen base attempt without attempting to understand the negative effect a CS produces. The success or failure of a SB attempt obviously influences the bases gained total of the batter, thereby directly impacting his value to the team in relation to its ability to score runs, so it should be counted. Ditto a player’s ability to draw BB and reach base for his teammates to knock him in. Any time that a player gains a base without making an out should be rewarded and that’s what SEC attempts to do.

Here is the equation that is used to figure SEC.

(TB - H + BB + SB - CS) / AB

Here is an example so you can see how easy it is to figure SEC.

Ex.
In 2004 Eric Chavez produced the following stats:
238 TB, 131 H, 95 BB, 6 SB, 3 CS, 475 AB.

Therefore…

(238-131+95+6-3) / 475
205 / 475
SEC = .43157 or .432

So, what SEC records is that in 2004 Eric Chavez’ offensive contribution was worth a SEC mark of .432. You barely even needed a calculator right?

SINGLE SEASON MARKS

2004 Season

B.Bonds 1.086 L. Berkman .487 T. Hafner .415
J. Edmonds .554 A. Pujols .468 C. Delgado .415
B. Abreu .524 M. Ramirez .445 M. Teixeira .409
T. Helton .510 B.Wilkerson .441 G. Sheffield .403
J. Drew .510 Er. Chavez .432 J. Posada .401
J. Thome .508 D. Ortiz .431 A Rod .399
A. Dunn .502 S. Rolen .430 M. Cameron .396
C. Beltran .499 Chip Jones .419 A. Beltre .391

What do you know, another list headed by Barry Bonds. Bonds’ SEC mark of 1.086 is the highest off all-time for a single season, no doubt largely influenced by his all-time record 232 BB. What is doubly shocking is the margin of his lead. The difference between Bonds and 2nd place Jim Edmonds was .532…or a total high enough to rank 3rd in baseball in 2004 if it were someone’s SEC mark! That means that Bonds’ SEC mark was almost double the next best player in baseball. Hell, the difference between Bonds and everyone else, .532, was so great that it would qualify as the 86th highest single season SEC mark ever!

Others worthy of mentioning…

How many of you noticed a fleet of foot, power hitting OF that went 30/30 last year (HR/SB) at the top of the list? Of course I’m talking about the # 3 man on the list Bobby Abreu, and not everyone’s favorite player of the year Carlos Beltran (who comes in 8th). Two other OF that finished ahead of Beltran were J.D. Drew and Adam Dunn, keep an eye ion them in 05’. Toward the bottom of the list is Mike Cameron, a player largely forgotten in the mediocrity of the Mets 2004 season. One last name that you might notice is omitted from our list, the 2004 AL MVP Vlad Guerrero. Did I fall asleep at the wheel and leave out the man who almost single-handedly won the West in 04’? You know me better than that don’t you? He finished 33rd (.366).

To put last year’s leaders into historical perspective here are the all-time single season leaders in SEC.

Season, All Time


Year SEC   Year SEC
Bonds 2004 1.086 Ruth 1926 .661
Bonds 2002 .938 Bonds 1992 .647
Bonds 2001 .929 T. Williams 1941 .647
Bonds 2003 .805 F. Thomas 1994 .647
Ruth 1920 .799 T. Williams 4954 .642
McGwire 1998 .774 Bonds 2000 .642
Ruth 1921 .744 Ruth 1928 .640
McGwire 1996 .693 Mantle 1961 .636
Ruth 1923 .690 Ruth 1930 .635
McGwire 1999 .674 Mantle 1957 .635
Ruth 1927 .672 Jack Clark 1987 .632
Bonds 1996 .663 Mantle 1962 .631
The Barry Bonds show continues. The top 4 marks of all-time are Bonds’ last 4 seasons…are you starting to see why some people say he is on the greatest run in the history of baseball?

Just like in my piece on Isolated Power we have the same three men dominating the top spots; Bonds, Babe Ruth and Mark McGwire. Whereas these three had 15 of the top 24 ISO single season marks, they have 17 of the top 24 SEC marks, including the top 14. There is also one guy who may not really belong on a list populated by HOF ballplayers but his 1987 season says that he belongs in their company. Of course that man, who violently lashed line drives to all fields as I grew up watching him in the orange and black at Candlestick Park is the Ripper, Jack Clark. It pains me to say it, but of course his 1987 season led the Cardinals, not the Giants, to the World Series (he actually helped to defeat the Giants in the playoffs before advancing to the Series against the Twinkies).

I would be remiss if I didn’t list the 2005 leaders but realize it has been barely over a month and there is a long, long way to go.

2005 Season
(leaders as of 5-9-05)

D. Dellucci .781 M. Ramirez .490 B. Abreu .409
A. Dunn .628 J. Kent .486 R. Klesko .406
L. Overbay .591 B. Giles .464 P. Konerko .405
D. Lee .569 R. Sexson .449 D. Ortiz .405
B. Roberts .549 D. Wright .431 T. Hafner .404
T. Glaus .540 J. Drew .424 C. Floyd .396
Chip Jones .535 R. Sanders .412 A. Soriano .391
J. Edmonds .494 P. Burrell .410 Arod .389

So, what does this 2005 list show us? First off, pick up Dave Dellucci right now in your fantasy league. Next, keep an eye on Dunn, believe that B. Giles will finish with his normal .300-25-95 line and don’t give up on Paul Konerko despite his poor AVG.

MULTIPLE YEAR TRENDS

Since we are in to threes in the fantasy world, here are the SEC marks, recorded as an average, for the last three years. How does your favorite player stack up?

2002-2004
B. Bonds .941 F. Thomas .458 S. Sosa .426
J. Thome .538 Br. Giles .456 R. Palmeiro .410
J. Edmonds .500 M. Ramirez .448 G. Sheffield .410
A. Dunn .477 A Rod .447 J. Drew .408
Ja. Giambi .469 B. Abreu .444 Chip Jones .405
T. Helton .466 C. Beltran .435 V. Guerrero .404
L. Berkman .465 L. Walker .429 L. Gonzalez .404
C. Delgado .460 A. Pujols .428 D. Ortiz .403

Again we are in a situation where Bonds’ three-year average is a greater mark than any other player has ever produced in a single season, dwarfing the .799 mark of Ruth from 1920. Jason Giambi, despite a horrible year in 2004, still has the 5th highest mark over the last three years. The same situation exists with Luis Gonzalez (Ari.), who had his 2004 season cut short by injury. And while Vlad Guerrero misses the SEC list for 2004, his three-year average places him 22nd.

I also thought you might be interested in seeing the career rankings of some of the best sluggers of all-time. And with that thought, here they are.

Career
(based on 2000 PA)

Bonds

.604 F.Thomas* .472 Schmidt .450
Ruth .594 Bill Joyce .471 Helton .444
T. Williams .553 Kiner .467 C. Keller .444
McGwire .539 Foxx .464 Killebrew .444
Thome .497 Greenberg .462 Bagwell .441
Mantle .487 Br. Giles .454 M. Ramirez .441
Gehrig .481 Ken Phelps .453 C. Delgado .440
Dunn .477 Berkman .452 Rickey Henderson .437

* Frank Thomas who plays for the White Sox (1990-current).

Who are some of these guys? Bill Joyce, well he played in the 1890’s. Ken Phelps…well he was that goofy looking guy with the big ole’ mustached and huge glasses that mostly Dh’d for the Mariners and Yankees. And Charlie Keller was an OF for the Yankees in the 1940’s. One guy that plays today but that you might be equally surprised to see on this all-time list is Dunn (he has been on almost every list hasn’t he?). Everyone tends to focus on what he doesn’t do well while overlooking the things he does really well. In fact, according to many of the sabermetric stats Dunn is one of the 20 best hitters in baseball. If you don’t believe me, look it up (you can start with: Serious Baseball #1).

In the end, Secondary Average is another that weapon you can deploy to get the jump on your friends in a bar room discussion or on draft day. Any way you slice it the more information that you that have at your disposal the better the decisions you will make. That is if you stay away from the beer when you are making your picks and trade offers…I’m sure we all have a story where one of our buddies took Kenny Lofton in the 8th round because in his drunken state he had a flashback and thought it was 1996. Ah, those were the days…

Ray Flowers, a member of SABR and FSWA, can be reached with comments/questions or suggestions at: ray@athomeplate.com. Please also visit Ray’s website at: www.wildpitch.blogspot.com for a plethora of baseball related posts and discussions.

 

 

Monthly Dynamic Promotion (125x125).  You never have to change this code - we make sure the monthly promo is always fresh!

In Association with Amazon.com

Ad Space for Sale

 

 

 

 

Home Archive Fantasy Forums Reviews Contact us Copyright 2002-5 At Home Plate, Inc.